To modern readers shaped by pluralism and academic detachment, the confrontational tone of the Bible may seem abrasive. But this response overlooks what the Bible truly is. It is not a disinterested theological reflection. It is a weapon. It is a series of books forged in the heart of a spiritual and historical rebellion. Its message was not formed in a vacuum but in the aftermath of Babel and the divine treason of the bene elohim who had been placed over the nations. Understanding the polemical nature of the Bible begins by understanding the world it was written to confront.
What Is a Polemic? And Why the ANE Was Full of Them
A polemic is a targeted argument or critique meant to expose, undermine, or discredit a rival idea, practice, or system. Unlike a simple disagreement or neutral description, a polemic is written to confront. It deliberately challenges an existing claim and seeks to replace it. In the ancient world, polemics were often theological, political, and cultural all at once. The gods, kings, and cities of rival nations were not treated as irrelevant. They were treated as threats that had to be addressed.
In the context of the Ancient Near East, polemics were deeply embedded in the stories nations told about themselves. Every origin story, temple hymn, or divine genealogy was not just a description of how things came to be. It was a claim of legitimacy. To say your god created the world or defeated the sea monster or chose your king was to declare supremacy over other peoples and their gods. It was to say, “Our story is the true one. Yours is a counterfeit.”
For example, when Babylon claimed that Marduk created the world by killing the goddess Tiamat, it was not just promoting cosmology. It was justifying Babylon’s imperial authority as the city of the supreme god. When Egypt said that Ma’at held the universe together through the Pharaoh’s divine rulership, it was declaring that Egyptian order was the divine ideal, and everyone else lived in chaos.
In such a world, writing something like Genesis 1 was not a quiet religious reflection. It was a direct challenge to every claim made by Egypt, Babylon, and Canaan. It was a polemic. And in the Bible, this polemical instinct is not occasional. It is foundational. Israel’s Scriptures were not meant to fit within the theological frameworks of other nations. They were meant to shatter them.
Babel and the Reordering of the World
Genesis 11 describes a human rebellion that goes far deeper than building a tower. At Babel, humanity attempted to unify under its own authority and defy Yahweh’s mandate to fill the earth. But the judgment that followed did more than scatter languages.
According to Deuteronomy 32:8–9, when Yahweh divided the nations, He appointed the bene elohim, divine sons of God, to oversee them. Only Israel would remain His direct possession.
The nations were not abandoned without guidance. But over time, the spiritual beings given authority over them failed in their stewardship. They began to crave worship and corrupted the justice they were meant to uphold. Psalm 82 records Yahweh standing in judgment over these divine rulers, declaring that they would fall like mortals. This cosmic judgment sets the stage for the mission of Israel and the tone of Scripture itself.
Israel: The Counter-Nation
Unlike the nations that inherited rebellious rulers, Israel was created from scratch. Yahweh did not reform an existing people. He called Abram from among the disinherited nations and made a new people who would be His portion. Israel was not simply chosen for privilege but created for purpose. As stated in Exodus 19:6, they were to be a kingdom of priests and a holy nation.
This priestly identity means Israel’s role was inherently polemical. Their laws, festivals, temples, and scriptures were not private religious expressions. They were public declarations that the gods of the nations were false, the powers behind them were corrupt, and that Yahweh alone was Most High over all the earth. The Bible, as the written witness of Israel’s calling, reflects this purpose.
Polemics in the Biblical Texts
The polemical nature of the Bible is woven deeply into its stories, laws, songs, and prophecies. These are not culturally isolated documents. They are intentional confrontations with the dominant worldviews shaped by the fallen gods of the nations.
Creation and the Flood
Genesis 1 is not merely an account of beginnings. It is a direct response to Mesopotamian creation myths such as Enuma Elish, which portray creation as the result of divine violence and chaos. In contrast, the biblical God creates through speech, with order and intention. There is no struggle, no divine bloodshed, no pantheon. It is a declaration that the gods of Babylon are not creators but pretenders.
Likewise, the flood account in Genesis 6–9 subverts the flood stories of the surrounding cultures. In the Epic of Gilgamesh, the gods send the flood in terror and regret it. In the Bible, the flood is just, purposeful, and moral. It is a surgical judgment on a world corrupted by human violence and divine rebellion, not the panicked act of unstable deities.
Conquest and the Defeat of the Gods
When Israel enters the land of Canaan, the conquest is not simply a political campaign. It is a cosmic battle against the corrupted spiritual rulers of the land. The defeat of Pharaoh in Egypt is explicitly described as Yahweh executing judgment on the gods of Egypt. The plagues are not random punishments but targeted humiliations of Egypt’s divine protectors.
Jericho’s fall, the silencing of Baal on Mount Carmel, the defeat of Dagon before the Ark in 1 Samuel 5, and the crushing of Leviathan imagery in the Psalms all follow the same pattern. The text is not just reporting history. It is declaring war on the false gods and the unseen rulers who manipulated the nations into darkness.
Psalms and Prophets as Weapons
The Psalms, often viewed only as worship poetry, are filled with divine council imagery and subversion of Canaanite theology. Psalm 29, for instance, uses storm language that sounds like a Baal hymn but places Yahweh as the one who rides the storm and subdues the waters. In Ugaritic myth, Baal defeats Yam to earn his throne. In the Bible, Yahweh sits enthroned above the flood before it ever lifts its head.
The prophets likewise deliver blistering critiques of the nations and their gods. Isaiah 19 declares judgment not just on Egypt but on its idols, priests, and necromancers. Ezekiel 28 mocks the divine claims of the Prince of Tyre, unmasking him as a fallen being in Eden. These are not veiled jabs. They are open condemnations of spiritual rebellion embedded in political empires.
The New Testament: The War Reaches Its Climax
By the time of Christ, the powers of the nations had not been dethroned. The world remained under their sway. Jesus refers to Satan as the ruler of this world and frames His ministry as a battle to bind the strong man and plunder his house. Every healing, exorcism, and storm-calming miracle is a polemic in action. Jesus is not just showing compassion. He is confronting the gods.
The cross itself is the ultimate polemic. It appears to be a defeat but is actually a triumph. As Paul writes in Colossians 2:15, Christ disarmed the rulers and authorities and put them to open shame. This is courtroom and battlefield language. The spiritual powers that once ruled unchallenged were publicly exposed as weak, condemned, and temporary.
The apostles carry this mission forward. Paul sees the preaching of the gospel as a cosmic declaration to the rulers and authorities in the heavenly realms. The church is not merely a new religious community. It is the living proof that the rebel gods have lost their grip, and that Yahweh is reclaiming the nations He once disinherited.
Conclusion
The Bible is not neutral because Yahweh is not indifferent. He is not one god among many. He is the Creator reclaiming a world that fell into enemy hands. Every passage of Scripture participates in this war, whether it is exposing lies, correcting myths, unmasking demonic powers, or declaring Yahweh’s unmatched glory.
Understanding the Bible as a polemic reshapes how we read it. It is not simply a spiritual guidebook or a collection of moral teachings. It is a divine proclamation in the midst of enemy territory. It confronts both the seen and unseen rulers of this age, announcing their defeat and calling all peoples to return to the true King.
To read Scripture faithfully is to join that confrontation. To teach it is to carry its sword. To believe it is to align with the One who is not just telling a better story, but reclaiming the entire world through it.
Discussion Questions
- How does the biblical account of Babel and the disinheriting of the nations explain why the Bible takes such an aggressive stance against other gods and worldviews?
- In what ways does recognizing Genesis 1 as a polemic against Ancient Near Eastern creation myths change how we understand its purpose?
- Why would Yahweh deliberately inspire Scripture that confronts and mocks the gods of Egypt, Canaan, Babylon, and later Rome? What does this say about the nature of divine revelation?
- How does the idea that Israel was created as a counter-nation help explain the structure, laws, and stories of the Old Testament?
- If the Bible is a sustained confrontation with both human and divine rebellion, what does that imply about the modern Church’s mission and how we read Scripture today?
Want to Know More?
- John D. Currid – Against the Gods: The Polemical Theology of the Old Testament
A focused study on how the Old Testament writers subverted the theological claims of surrounding cultures, showing that Israel’s Scriptures were intentionally written to confront false worldviews. Currid demonstrates that biblical authors used familiar imagery to challenge and correct the messages of pagan religions. - John H. Walton – The Lost World of Genesis One: Ancient Cosmology and the Origins Debate
Walton argues that Genesis 1 should be understood within the context of ANE temple dedication texts. His work shows how the Bible adopts and transforms cultural ideas into a bold declaration of Yahweh’s supremacy, making the creation account itself a theological polemic. - John N. Oswalt – The Bible Among the Myths: Unique Revelation or Just Ancient Literature?
Oswalt distinguishes biblical thought from the mythologies of Israel’s neighbors. While ANE texts affirm a cyclical, chaotic view of reality, the Bible presents a radically different, linear, moral, and covenantal worldview. This work highlights the confrontational nature of biblical revelation. - James B. Pritchard (ed.) – Ancient Near Eastern Texts Relating to the Old Testament (ANET)
This classic sourcebook compiles key texts from the cultures surrounding Israel, including creation myths, flood narratives, and royal inscriptions. Comparing these texts with Scripture makes the Bible’s polemical posture unmistakable. - Michael S. Heiser – The Unseen Realm: Recovering the Supernatural Worldview of the Bible
Heiser restores the divine council worldview that shaped the biblical authors, showing how the Bible confronts and corrects spiritual rebellion in both human and heavenly realms. This work provides essential background for understanding the Bible’s cosmic polemic and Yahweh’s plan to reclaim the nations.
About the Author
