Theology in Five

Introduction

Jonathan Cahn, an influential Christian author, has made waves with his books such as “The Harbinger” and “The Mystery of the Shemitah,” presenting biblical prophecy as a tool to interpret modern-day events. While Cahn’s books are compelling and have garnered a significant following, inconsistencies with his predictive patterns and actual outcomes call for a more critical examination.

Inconsistent Pattern Fulfillment

A significant criticism of Cahn’s work, particularly “The Mystery of the Shemitah,” centers around the inconsistent fulfillment of his predictive patterns. Cahn posits a seven-year cycle of economic downturns corresponding to the Shemitah year (a Sabbath year in the Jewish calendar). However, many of his foreseen financial crises either did not transpire or did not coincide with the Shemitah year. Some significant economic crises in recent history do not fit this supposed cycle, casting doubt on Cahn’s interpretations’ validity.

Selective Use of Data

Critics argue that Cahn employs a selective use of data to substantiate his theories. He focuses on instances that align with his patterns and seems to downplay or disregard instances that do not. This selective use of data undermines the overall credibility of his arguments and suggests a potential confirmation bias in his methodology.

Contextual Interpretation of Scripture

One recurring issue in Cahn’s work is the extraction of verses from their original biblical context to serve his theories. An instance of this is found in “The Harbinger,” where Cahn applies Isaiah 9:10—a warning to ancient Israel—to the United States in the aftermath of the 9/11 attacks. This approach sidesteps the original context of the scripture and is generally cautioned against by biblical scholars.

The Concept of America as a New Israel

A foundational belief in Cahn’s works is the notion that America stands as a modern counterpart to ancient Israel in God’s plan. However, this idea lacks explicit biblical support. Asserting that America is subject to the specific covenants God made with ancient Israel invites theological controversy. This does not discount America having a major role in spreading the Gospel and being a Christian nation, but there is no evidence of God making a covenant with the founders in a similar fashion to Israel.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while Jonathan Cahn’s books offer intriguing narratives, they call for a discerning and critical readership. Christian literature should, above all, inspire a deeper engagement with the Bible as the irreplaceable source of spiritual truth and guidance.

Discussion Questions:

1. How does the inconsistency between Cahn’s predictive patterns and actual events affect your perception of his works?
2. How does the selective use of data influence your understanding of Cahn’s theories?
3. In what ways does the recontextualization of biblical verses impact the authenticity of Cahn’s interpretations?
4. What are the theological implications of equating America with ‘New Israel,’ as suggested by Cahn’s theories?
5. How should Christian literature guide our engagement and understanding of the Bible?

Want to Know More?

1. “Has America Received God’s Prophetic Warning?: A Biblical Examination of The Harbinger” by Doug Hammett – This book provides a critical examination of Jonathan Cahn’s “The Harbinger,” assessing its biblical interpretations and applications to modern events.
2. James Prasch. (2014). “Harbinger: Fact or Fiction?”. Moriel Ministries. This critical review delves into the many problems Prasch, a well-respected biblical scholar, finds in Cahn’s work, notably “The Harbinger”.
3. David James. (2012). “The Harbinger: Fact or Fiction?”. The Alliance for Biblical Integrity. This book by David James provides a comprehensive, verse-by-verse critique of “The Harbinger”, questioning its interpretations and conclusions.
4. T.A. McMahon. (2015). “The Shemitah: The Fallacy of Predictive Prophecies”. The Berean Call. McMahon scrutinizes the predictions made in “The Mystery of the Shemitah” and challenges their lack of fulfillment and departure from traditional biblical interpretation.

Image attribution: Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported (CC BY-SA 3.0). Image uploaded to Wikimedia Commons by Benny Hinn Ministries.